Eight lawn mowers ranked by yard size and type: cordless push and self-propelled, electric and gas riding, and a manual reel. Specs, trade-offs and who each suits.
B By the Best Lawn Mower editorial team ·Published
At a glance
For most yards, start with the EGO Power+ LM2135SP Select Cut, a self-propelled cordless mower with swappable blades. The Toro 60V MAX 21" Recycler Self-Propel suits yards up to about a third of an acre, and the EGO Power+ Z6 ZT4204L is the electric riding option for large lawns.
Choosing a lawn mower mostly comes down to three decisions: how big your yard is, whether you want a battery or a gas engine, and how much of the walking and pushing you want to do yourself. We compared the manufacturer specifications of eight mowers that cover the main types, from a manual reel mower to a zero-turn rider, and ranked them for the typical American homeowner. Each mower has its own profile page with a full rundown of specs, linked below.
A note on how to read the ranking: the order reflects how widely a mower fits real yards and how complete the package is, not a single winner for every lawn. A manual reel mower can be the right answer for a small, short lawn, and a zero-turn is the right answer for two acres, even though neither of them sits at the top. Use the Picks by Use and Budget section near the end if you already know your yard size.
How We Chose
We rank mowers on published specifications, not on our own driving. We compared what each maker lists on its official page and read those figures against general lawn-care guidance from university extension sources. Here are the criteria we weighed.
Yard size and mower type. This is the first filter. As a rough guide, a small lot suits a light push mower or a reel mower, a typical suburban lawn suits a 21-inch push or self-propelled mower, and one acre or more starts to favor a riding mower. Toro, for example, says its 21-inch Recycler suits yards up to 1/3 acre, while Craftsman and EGO list up to 2 acres for their 42-inch zero-turns.
Push, self-propelled or riding. A push mower is the lightest and simplest. Self-propel adds drive to the wheels so you steer rather than push, which matters on slopes and longer lawns. Riding mowers and zero-turns trade storage space and cost for speed.
Battery versus gas. Cordless mowers skip gas, oil and pull cords. The trade-off is runtime, which depends on grass height, thickness and moisture, so every runtime figure in this ranking is a manufacturer best case. Gas engines refuel in minutes but need seasonal maintenance.
Deck width and cutting heights. A wider deck means fewer passes. Cutting height range matters just as much: Ohio State University Extension lists 2.0 to 4.0 inches for Kentucky bluegrass and 2.5 to 4.0 for tall fescue, so a mower whose maximum height is 2.52 inches fits some lawns poorly.
Bag, mulch and discharge. Most 21-inch models are 3-in-1, meaning mulching, bagging and side discharge. Extension guidance says leaving mulched clippings reduces fertilizer needs, while bagging helps when weeds are seeding.
Storage and warranty. Folding handles and vertical storage matter in a one-car garage. We also note the warranty each maker lists, since terms differ between the tool and the battery.
Summary Table
#
Mower
Type
Power
Deck
Cutting heights
Best for
1
EGO Power+ LM2135SP Select Cut
Self-propelled push
56V 7.5Ah battery
21 in.
8 positions, 1 to 4 in.
Lawns up to about 1/2 acre
2
Toro 60V MAX 21” Recycler Self-Propel
Self-propelled push
60V 5.0Ah battery
21 in.
1.25 to 3.75 in.
Yards up to 1/3 acre
3
EGO Power+ Z6 ZT4204L
Electric zero-turn rider
Four 56V 10.0Ah batteries
42 in.
10 positions, 1.5 to 4.5 in.
Large open lawns
4
Craftsman Z5200 42” Zero-Turn
Gas zero-turn rider
20 HP Kohler gas engine
42 in.
Not listed by maker
One to two acres
5
EGO Power+ LM2125SP Touch Drive
Self-propelled push
56V 7.5Ah battery
21 in.
7 positions, 1.25 to 4 in.
Typical suburban lawns
6
Toro 60V MAX 21” Recycler SmartStow Push
Push
60V Max Flex-Force battery
21 in.
1.25 to 3.75 in.
Simple cordless mowing, upright storage
7
Sun Joe 24V-MJ14C
Push
24V 4.0Ah battery
14 in.
3 positions, 1.18 to 2.52 in.
Small lawns, tight storage
8
American Lawn Mower 1415-16 Reel Mower
Manual reel
Your own push
16 in.
Cutting length 1/2 to 2-1/4 in.
Small, short lawns
1. EGO Power+ LM2135SP Select Cut — The Most Flexible 21-Inch Mower
Our top pick for owners of suburban lawns up to roughly half an acre who want a self-propelled cordless mower they can set up for different mowing jobs.
What we like
Select Cut system swaps between mulching, high-lift bagging and extended-runtime lower blades
Touch Drive self-propel with variable speed from 0.9 to 3.1 MPH
5-year tool warranty and 3-year battery warranty according to EGO
Drawbacks
Premium-tier mower that costs more than basic 21-inch cordless models
EGO's 60-minute runtime is a best case that depends on grass and blade choice
The LM2135SP earns the top spot because it combines a full-size deck, self-propel and the most adjustable blade setup in this group. According to EGO, the Select Cut system pairs an upper blade with three interchangeable lower blades: Mulching, High Lift Bagging and Extended Runtime. You pick the lower blade for the job, so you can chop clippings finely in normal weeks, bag when weeds are seeding, or favor runtime on a larger lawn.
The drive is EGO’s Touch Drive, which EGO describes as variable speed from 0.9 to 3.1 MPH, so the mower follows your walking pace. The brushless motor delivers up to 7.0 ft-lbs of cutting torque, the deck has eight cutting height positions from 1 to 4 inches, and the kit includes a 56V 7.5Ah battery, a Rapid Charger and a two-bushel bag. EGO lists up to 60 minutes of runtime per charge with that battery, and bright LED headlights for early or late mowing. The warranty is 5 years on the tool and 3 years on the battery.
The trade-offs are cost and the usual cordless caveat. This is a premium-tier mower, and the 60-minute figure is a best case. Thick, wet or tall grass and the mulching blade all draw more power, so lawns beyond about half an acre are better served by a second battery. See the full breakdown in our EGO LM2135SP Select Cut profile.
2. Toro 60V MAX 21” Recycler Self-Propel — A Solid Mid-Range Choice
Toro’s model 21326 is the practical pick for the typical suburban lot. Toro lists a 21-inch Recycler deck in 15-gauge steel, rear-wheel-drive self-propel with variable speed, and a brushless motor. The included 60V 5.0Ah battery (270Wh) is rated for up to 43 minutes of run time, and Toro says the mower suits yards up to 1/3 acre. Cutting height runs from 1.25 to 3.75 inches in two-point adjustment.
Mulching and bagging are standard, with a 2.0-bushel bagger. The side discharge chute is not in the box, but Toro says it is free with product registration at Toro.com/register, so order it early if you plan to side discharge. The mower weighs 65 lbs, the SmartStow folding handle is said to reduce the storage footprint by up to 70 percent, and the warranty is 2 years on the mower and 3 years on the battery.
Two practical points. Charge time is listed at 230 minutes, so charge before a big mowing day. And this is not the Personal Pace model: that name belongs to Toro’s 22-inch mowers. The mower also shares its battery with Toro’s Flex-Force 60V tools, which is a real advantage if you already own them. Read our Toro 60V MAX 21” Recycler profile for more.
3. EGO Power+ Z6 ZT4204L — The Electric Riding Option
When a yard outgrows a walk-behind mower, the Z6 is the gas-free way up. EGO lists a 42-inch deck with two 21-inch blades, a speed of 3 to 7 MPH (up to 8 MPH in travel mode) and ten cutting height positions from 1.5 to 4.5 inches. The kit includes four 56V 10.0Ah ARC Lithium batteries and a 1600W charger, and the mower holds up to six batteries.
EGO’s figures are up to 2 acres per charge with the four included batteries and up to 3 acres with six. Charging four batteries takes about 2 hours on the included charger, according to EGO. There is no gas, oil or engine maintenance, and the limited warranty runs 5 years on the tool, battery and charger.
The caveats are cost and terrain. A zero-turn steers with two lap bars and responds differently from a steering-wheel tractor, so practice in an open area first. EGO says it handles 15-degree slopes only under ideal conditions, and that traction depends on moisture, sidehilling, tire pressure, drive mode and speed. The Consumer Product Safety Commission calls slopes a major hazard for riding mowers, so treat hills with respect. Details are in our EGO Z6 ZT4204L profile.
4. Craftsman Z5200 42” Zero-Turn — The Traditional Gas Rider
The Z5200 is the conventional counterpart to the EGO Z6. According to Craftsman, it has a 20 HP Kohler 7000 series twin-cylinder gas engine (the rating is as certified by the engine maker, and actual output may vary), a 42-inch stamped steel deck and a dual hydrostatic transmission. The seat is a high-back, cut-and-sew leather design, and the lap bars have three adjustable positions. Craftsman lists coverage of up to 2 acres and a 3-year limited warranty, and says it is made in Martin, Tennessee, with some global materials.
The pros are quick refueling and a setup many owners already know. The cons are what comes with any gas engine: fuel, oil, filters and seasonal maintenance. A mulching kit is an optional add-on, so check what you need before ordering, and Craftsman does not list speed or fuel capacity.
Slope safety applies here too. The CPSC says riding mowers can overturn on slopes and drivers can fall off, so follow the operator’s manual. See the Craftsman Z5200 profile.
5. EGO Power+ LM2125SP Touch Drive — Self-Propel Without the Extras
The LM2125SP is the simpler sibling of our number one. EGO lists a 21-inch deck, up to 6.0 ft-lbs of cutting torque, seven cutting height positions from 1.25 to 4 inches, a two-bushel bag and a 56V 7.5Ah battery in the kit. Runtime is up to 60 minutes per charge, and charging takes about 60 minutes with the Rapid Charger. The mower folds flat for compact storage, and the warranty is 5 years on the tool and 3 years on the battery.
Its self-propel speed is set with a dial, so you walk at your own pace. Compared with the LM2135SP you give up the Select Cut blade swap and the extra height positions. If you mostly mulch and your lawn is a normal suburban size, that is a fair trade. As with every cordless mower here, runtime depends on grass height and density, and bigger lawns may need a second battery. Our EGO LM2125SP profile has the full list.
6. Toro 60V MAX 21” Recycler SmartStow Push — A Plain Cordless Push Mower With Upright Storage
This Toro is the straightforward option: according to Toro, it has a 21-inch, 15-gauge steel Recycler deck, a brushless motor, cutting heights from 1.25 to 3.75 inches, and mulching and bagging as standard with a 2.0-bushel bag. Toro says it cuts up to a third of an acre in 42 minutes or less on a full charge, which is a best case that depends on the grass.
Toro says the SmartStow folding handle and deck lock can reduce the storage footprint by up to 70 percent, and lists a 2-year limited warranty on the mower. The side discharge chute is not in the box, but Toro says it is free after registration. Battery capacity is the one detail to verify: the Amazon kit title says 5.0Ah, while Toro’s page for model 21323 lists a 4.0Ah pack. The main limit is that it is a push mower, so it sits below the self-propelled models for hilly or longer lawns. See the Toro 60V SmartStow Push profile.
7. Sun Joe 24V-MJ14C — The Lightweight Small-Lawn Pick
The Sun Joe is the smallest powered mower here. Sun Joe lists a 600 W brushless motor, a 14-inch cutting path, three height positions from 1.18 to 2.52 inches, and a 24V 4.0Ah battery with charger. It weighs 23.1 lbs with the battery installed, has a collapsible handle and a detachable 10.6-gallon bag, and carries a 2-year limited warranty. Sun Joe lists it for small to medium-sized lawns.
The limits follow from the numbers. A 14-inch path means more passes, and a 2.52-inch top height is low for many cool-season lawns, where Extension guidance recommends 2.0 to 4.0 inches or more. Sun Joe does not publish a runtime, so check the manual before you buy. For a small yard and a crowded garage, though, it is easy to live with. Read the Sun Joe 24V-MJ14C profile.
8. American Lawn Mower 1415-16 Reel Mower — No Motor at All
The 1415-16 is last because it fits the fewest lawns, not because it is poor at its job. According to American Lawn Mower Company, it has a 16-inch cutting width, five blades on a ball-bearing reel made of tempered alloy steel, an adjustable four-section roller with a cutting length of 1/2 to 2-1/4 inches, and 10-inch molded plastic wheels. It needs no gas, oil or electricity, and the maker recommends regular lubrication of the bearings and blades.
The maker says it works best on grass no longer than 3 to 4 inches. Ohio State University Extension notes that reel mowers give a clean, precision cut that suits low mowing heights and southern zoysia or bermudagrass, but struggle with the higher heights now recommended for cool-season grasses. So it suits a small, fairly flat lawn mowed frequently. See the American Lawn Mower 1415-16 profile.
Picks by Use and Budget
Top pick for most yards: the EGO Power+ LM2135SP Select Cut, for its self-propel, blade options and full-size deck.
Best for a typical suburban lot: the Toro 60V MAX 21” Recycler Self-Propel, if your yard is up to about a third of an acre, or the EGO Power+ LM2125SP Touch Drive if you want a speed dial and a larger battery system.
Best if you want to ride: for large, open lawns, the EGO Power+ Z6 ZT4204L is the gas-free choice and the Craftsman Z5200 42” Zero-Turn is the gas choice. Their makers rate both for up to 2 acres or more, but neither belongs on steep ground.
Best simple cordless push mower: the Toro 60V MAX 21” Recycler SmartStow Push.
Best for a small yard and tight storage: the Sun Joe 24V-MJ14C.
Best no-motor option: the American Lawn Mower 1415-16 Reel Mower, for short, small, flat lawns.
On budget, the order is easy to read from the table. The entry-level group is the Sun Joe and the reel mower, the mid-range group is the 21-inch cordless push and self-propelled models, and the premium group is the Select Cut mower and the two riding mowers. Check the price on Amazon before you decide, and weigh battery and warranty, not just the sticker.
Safety Basics Before You Mow
The Consumer Product Safety Commission advises wearing sturdy shoes, never removing safety guards or shields, never mowing when tired or in a hurry, and stopping the mower and waiting for the blades to stop before clearing a chute. It also says never to permit children to use a mower and to keep children and bystanders out of the area, since objects can be thrown from discharge chutes. Slopes are a major hazard for riding mowers, and mowing on an incline is risky with any mower because a foot can slip under the blades.
Conclusion
The short version: the EGO Power+ LM2135SP Select Cut is the most capable mower for most yards, the Toro 60V MAX 21” Recycler Self-Propel is the sensible choice for a third of an acre or less, and the EGO Power+ Z6 ZT4204L is how to go electric on a big lawn. The Craftsman Z5200 42” Zero-Turn is the gas alternative for large lawns. Below those, the EGO Power+ LM2125SP Touch Drive trims the extras, the Toro 60V MAX 21” Recycler SmartStow Push keeps things simple, the Sun Joe 24V-MJ14C fits small lawns and small garages, and the American Lawn Mower 1415-16 Reel Mower needs no power at all.
Whatever you choose, match the mower to your grass height, your slope and your storage space, and confirm current specs and warranty terms with the maker before you buy.
Match the mower to the lawn. For small lots, a 14-inch push or a 16-inch reel can work. Typical suburban lawns suit a 21-inch cordless mower, ideally self-propelled if the yard has some slope. For one to two acres of open grass, a 42-inch riding or zero-turn mower saves a lot of time.
Are cordless electric mowers as good as gas?
For small and mid-size lawns, a cordless mower with a 5.0Ah to 7.5Ah battery is a practical alternative and removes gas, oil and pull cords. Runtime depends on grass height, thickness and moisture, and makers quote best-case figures, so plan for a second battery on larger lawns.
Is a self-propelled mower worth it?
It is worth considering if your lawn has slopes, is bigger than a small lot, or you simply want less strain. Self-propel drives the wheels so you steer rather than push. On a small, flat lawn, a push mower is usually enough.
How high should I cut my grass?
Ohio State University Extension lists 2.0 to 4.0 inches for Kentucky bluegrass, perennial ryegrass and fine fescues, 2.5 to 4.0 for tall fescue, 1.0 to 2.5 for zoysiagrass and 1.0 to 2.0 for common bermudagrass. It also advises never removing more than a third of the leaf blade at once.
Are riding mowers safe on hills?
Slopes are a major hazard. The Consumer Product Safety Commission says riding mowers can overturn on slopes and that mowing on an incline also risks a foot slipping under the blades. Follow the slope limits in the operator's manual and use a walk-behind mower on steep ground.
Should I mulch or bag my clippings?
Ohio State University Extension says clippings are nutrient-rich, decompose quickly and do not cause thatch, so leaving them on the lawn reduces fertilizer needs. Bagging makes sense when weeds are seeding or when disease is active.